Online Learning Portal
Monthly DNA
21 Nov, 2023
29 Min Read
Constitutional Provisions related to Governor
Historical Background
Governor- Issues and Suggested Reforms
Constitutional provisions
|
What are the recent controversies associated with the office of Governor?
Tamil Nadu |
Governor refusing to read some parts of the Governor’s address which is prepared by the State govt. |
West Bengal |
Governor and state govt face off after the WB Assembly passed a Bill paving the way for making the Chief Minister the Chancellor of State Universities replacing the Governor from the position. |
Kerala |
Governor touring the state without any previous announcements. |
Jharkhand |
The Governor didn’t act on the advice of the Election Commission of India to disqualify the Chief Minister of Jharkhand for violation of electoral norms. This resulted in prolonged political uncertainity in the state. |
Maharastra |
The Governor hastily removed the Governor’s rule and administered oath to a CM who lacked majority support. |
Rajasthan |
The Governor inordinate delay in convening the assembly session for the government to prove its majority. |
What is the history and rationale behind the office of Governor?
Pre Independence |
Government of India Act 1858- Provincial Governors were agents of the crown, functioning under the supervision of the Governor-General. |
Post Independence |
The Office of the Governor was retained Post Independence. Governor was envisaged to be the Constitutional Head of a state. However, the Governor retained special responsibilities and discretionary power. |
What are the Issues Related to the Post of Governor in India?
1. Affiliation Based Appointment- Politicians and former bureaucrats affiliated with the ruling party have been appointed in several instances as Governors. This has led to questions about the post’s impartiality and non-partisanship.
2. Arbitrary Removal of Governors- There are no written grounds or procedures for removing governors. This leads to arbitrary removals especially when there is change of political power at the Union Govt. level.
3. From Centre’s Representative to Centre’s Agent- The governors have become the ‘agents of the Centre’ as they are appointed and removed by the Central Government.
4. Governor recommending President’s Rule- The discretionary power of governor recommending president’s rule on account of the failure of constitutional machinery in the state has has not always been based on ‘objective material’. Political partisanship, whims and fancies have also played their part.
5. No Clear Distinction Between Constitutional and Statutory Role- The constitutional mandate of the Governor to act on advice of the council of ministers is not clearly distinguished from his statutory authority as chancellor. This has resulted in many conflicts between the governor and the state government. For ex- The was a recent appointment of a Vice Chancellor in a university by the Kerala Governor, bypassing government nominations has caused a conflict.
6. Misuse of Discretionary power of appointment of CM- The Office of governor has been accused of playing a partisan role in the appointment of CM in cases where a single party lacks the majority.
7. Convening and Dissolution of Assembly- The Office of Governor has been associated with the politics of delay in the convening and dissolution of state legislative assembly.
8. Delay in giving assent to the Bills- There is no time limit set for how long a Governor can withhold assent to a Bill. This has been misuded by the Office of the Governor to withhold assents to Bills passed by the State legislative Assemblies.
What about the Governor’s role in giving assent to Bills?
What are the Constitutional Reforms suggested by Various Committees and Supreme Court?
Various Rulings of the Supreme Court arranged in Chrnological Order-
1. Shamsher Singh vs. State of Punjab(1974)- The Supreme Court held that the Governor is bound to act in accordance with the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister. Article 154(1) makes it clear that the executive power of the State is vested in the Governor, but shall be exercised by him in accordance with the Constitution.
2. SR Bommai vs. Union of India (1994)- The case was concerned with the use of Article 356 and the Governor’s power to dismiss a State Government. The Supreme Court ruled that whether the State Government has the majority should be tested on the floor of the House. It shouldn’t be based on the subjective assessment of the Governor.
3. Rameshwar Prasad vs. Union of India (2006)- The Supreme Court held the Governor’s decision to dissolve the Assembly as unconstitutional and mala fide. Motivated and whimsical conduct of the Governor in recommending president’s rule is amenable to judicial review.
4. BP Singhal vs Union of India (2010)- The SC held that the removal of Governor cannot be based on arbitrary, capricious or unreasonable grounds.
5. Nabam Rebia vs. Deputy Speaker (2016)- The Governor had went against the advice of the State Cabinet and called the session of the Legislative Assembly at an earlier date (against the recommended date). The SC confirmed that the Governor does not enjoy broad discretionary powers and is always subject to Constitutional standards. The Court concluded that the Governor’s discretion did not extend to the powers conferred under Article 174 (Article 174 is related to the Sessions of the State Legislature, prorogation and dissolution). Hence, the Governor could not summon the House, determine its legislative agenda or address the legislative assembly without consultation.
Recommendations of Various Commissions in Chronological Order
1. The Administrative Reforms Commission (1969)- The Commission recommended that non-partisan persons having long experience in public life and administration should be appointed as the Governors of a State.
2. Sarkaria Commission (1988)-
(a) Appointment of Governor-
(i) The Governor should be appointed after consultations with the Chief Minister of the State
(ii) The Governor should be eminent in some walk of life and from outside the State
(iii) The person should be a detached figure without intense political links, or should not have taken part in politics in the recent past
(iv) The person should not be a member of the ruling party
(b) Removal of Governor-
(i) The Governor should be removed before the end of the term (5 years) only on the grounds if doubts are raised about his morality, dignity, constitutional propriety etc.
(ii) In the process of removal before the end of the term, the State Government may be informed and consulted
(c) Use of Article 356-
This article should be used very sparingly and as a matter of last resort. It can be invoked only in the event of political crisis, internal subversion, physical breakdown, and non-compliance with the Constitutional directives of the Centre.
3. National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC), 2002- The Governor should be appointed by a Committee comprising the Prime Minister, Home Minister, Speaker of the Lok Sabha, and the Chief Minister of the State concerned.
4. The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (ARC), 2008- The Inter-State Council needs to come up with some guidelines for governors to follow when they are using their discretionary power.
5. Punchhi Commission (2010)–
(a) It proposed giving Governors a fixed term of 5 years and removing them through an impeachment process (similar to that of the President) by the State Legislature. The doctrine of pleasure (for removal of Governors) should be deleted
(b) It reiterated the recommendation of the Sarkaria Commission regarding appointment of Governors. The person shouldn’t be active in politics
(c) The convention of making the Governors as chancellors of universities should be done away with
(d) Article 355 and 356 should be amended to allow the Union Government to bring specific troubled areas under its rule for a limited period, instead of the whole State.
Way Forward
India and the UK are negotiating a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) that will reduce tariffs and non-tariff barriers on goods and services.
What is a Free Trade Agreement?
India-UK Free Trade Agreement (FTA) |
|
What are the benefits of India-UK FTA?
For India
For UK
What are the challenges with the India-UK FTA?
What lies ahead?
China is prioritising the extension of the China-Myanmar Economic Corridor (CMEC) to Sri Lanka.
Project South Asia under the BRI project |
|
India and Bhutan are the only countries in South Asia that have stayed out of the BRI.
Significance – China will be able to shift its manufacturing to its south-western provinces to avoid the middle-income trap.
Recently, India and Australia held 2+2 Ministerial Dialogue to step up defence cooperation and deepen the strategic relationship in sectors such as critical minerals and trade and investment.
At present, India has 2+2 dialogue with UK (2023), Australia (2021), Russia (2021), Japan (2019) and USA (2018).
In a recent landmark study, scientists reported the successful generation of a live chimera in non-human primates.
What is chimera?
In Greek mythology, a chimera was a fearsome creature with the combined features of a lion, a goat, and a snake.
Types |
About |
Animal chimeras |
It results from the merger of two or more embryos. They may possess blood cells of different blood types and subtle variations in form. |
Plant chimeras |
It can have distinct types of tissue originating from the same zygote due to mutation during ordinary cell division. |
Hybrid chimeras |
An individual where each cell contains genetic material from two organisms of different breeds, varieties, species or genera. |
Organ transplantation |
The tissues from a different genome are introduced to an individual. Example- Bone marrow transplantation can determine the recipient's ensuing blood type. |
What are the key findings of the study?
What are the advantages and challenges of the chimeras?
Advantages |
Challenges |
|
|
Researchers from the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Ropar has detected the presence of tantalum, a rare metal, in the Sutlej river sand in Punjab.
Sutlej River is longest of the 5 tributaries of the Indus River that give the Punjab (meaning “Five Rivers”) region its name. 80% of the catchment area of River Sutlej is in China.
Critical mineral is a metallic or non-metallic element that is essential for the functioning of our modern technologies, economies or national security. They are 30 in number in India.
So, Rani Lakshmi Bai took part in the Indian Rebellion of 1857 and died on the battlefield in June 1858.
The Constitution came into effect on January 26, 1950.
The park is named after former Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Kasu Brahmananda Reddy
India is the world’s largest arms importer and Russia remains its largest supplier (45%) with France providing 29% and the United States 11%.
Some of India's inland capture fisheries resources include - Godavari, Krishna, Cauvery, Bhima, West Coast Narmada, Tapti, Mahi.
The Atlantic Ocean borders Liberia to the south-southwest.
Sand sedimentation is causing the mudflats of Kadalundi to vanish. Kadalundi – A village on the southwest coast in Kozhikode, Kerala that had about 8 hectares of nutrient rich intertidal mudflats in the early 2000s. Kadalundi River is the 6th longe
Some large industrialised meat and dairy companies promotes a new metric for measuring methane emissions, called GWP* as a more accurate way to calculate emissions from the greenhouse gas (GHG). GWP – It tells us how much heat a greenhouse gas (GHG) traps in the atmosphere. It
According to a new study, deforestation in the Maritime Continent (MC) can strengthen subtropical El Nino-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) dynamics, causing more Central Pacific and multi-year ENSOs. ENSO is an important climate phenomenon on Earth due to its ability to change the global atmosphe
Union ministry of ports, shipping and waterways reinstated the Vadhavan Port project in Maharashtra, after it had been stuck over environmental concerns for over 2 years. It is India's 13th major port, developed as a joint venture by the Jawaharlal Nehru Port Authority (JNPA) and
It is the world's 1st ever AI humanoid robot CEO of Polish rum company Dictador. It is developed by Dictador and Hanson Robotics, a Hong Kong-based engineering and robotics company which is behind the renowned AI robot Sophia. Mika is a more advanced version of her siste
Union Minister for Cooperation has recently launched the ‘Bharat Organics’ brand of National Cooperative Organics Ltd (NCOL). 6 products under the 'Bharat Organics' brand were tur dal, chana dal, sugar, rajma, basmati rice, and Sonamasoori rice. About 50% of profits fro
Recently, the US President Joe Biden and the Chinese President Xi Jinping met on the sidelines of the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Summit in San Francisco in 2023. What are the key highlights of US-China Summit? High level diplomacy- Apparent realisation that high-leve
To cut down on plastic pollution, plastic credits are one of the tools being considered in UN-led talks in Nairobi. What are plastic credits? Plastic credits - It is a market based mechanism that allows companies or individuals to pay for plastic waste collectio
Recently, Uttar Pradesh government has ordered a state-wide ban on products being sold with halal certificates. An Arabic word meaning ‘permissible’ in English. In India, it mostly refers to the slaughtering technique of Muslims. As per Islamic dietary laws, it refers
The United States and the Philippines have recently signed a nuclear deal that would allow Washington to export nuclear technology and material to Manila, Philippines. The pact is in adherence with non-proliferation requirements.
It is the world-1st rifle protection ballistic helmet, indigenously developed by Kanpur-based MKU Limited. It offers uniform protection in all 5 zones of the head against threats like the AK-47 MSC, M80 NATO BALL, and M193 rifle bullets. ‘Back Face Signature&rsquo
Our Popular Courses
Module wise Prelims Batches
Mains Batches
Test Series