×

UPSC Courses

DNA banner

DAILY NEWS ANALYSIS

Monthly DNA

16 Feb, 2023

25 Min Read

Custodial Death in India

GS-II : Governance Custodial Crime

Custodial Death in India

Gujarat reported 80 custody deaths during the course of the last five years, according to the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA).

Difference between custody and arrest:

  • When someone is kept in protective custody, it is because authorities fear they will pose a risk to society it is known as custody.
  • When someone is officially brought into police custody on suspicion of committing a crime, it is referred to as an "arrest." Custody exists in every arrest, but the reverse is not true.

Judicial custody vs police custody:

Police custody:

  • It is the term used to describe the process by which a suspect in a crime is taken into custody by a police officer and transported to the police station.
  • When in police custody, the suspect is questioned by the officer in charge while being held for no more than 24 hours in a prison at a police station.
  • Within 24 hours of detention, police officers must bring the accused before the judge.

Judicial custody:

  • In this, the accused is held in the custody of the local magistrate rather than in the actual custody of the police as in police custody.
  • Unlike police custody, when the suspect is kept in police custody, judicial custody involves keeping the accused in jail.
  • Unless the court determines that the police officer's opinion is supported by the evidence presented to the court, the investigating police officer is not permitted to question the suspect while in judicial custody.

Custody and judicial remand under CrPC in India:

  • The Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) covers regulations relating to judicial remand and custody of an individual.
  • A police officer is not permitted to hold a person in custody for longer than 24 hours in accordance with Section 57 of the CrPC.
  • According to Section 167 of the CrPC, the officer must ask the magistrate for special authorization before holding a suspect for longer than 24 hours.

What is custodial death?

An accused person dies while in custody, either before a trial or after being found guilty.

Police misconduct while in prison, whether direct or indirect, is to blame for the death.

It covers deaths that take place not just in jails but also in hospitals or private property, or even in cars like police or other vehicles. Three categories can be used to categorize fatalities in custody:

  • In police custody, the death happened.
  • In judicial custody, the death happened.
  • The person passed while under the army's or paramilitary's control.
  • The offense committed by a public employee against the person who has been arrested or detained and is in custody constitutes custodial violence, according to the Law Commission of India.

International laws dealing with Human Rights:

Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 (UDHR):

  • Every person should be viewed as innocent until proven guilty, according to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
  • The topics of torture and cruelty are covered under Article 5 of the UDHR. No one should be tortured or abused cruelly, according to Article 5 of the UDHR, regardless of where they are in the world.

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966:

  • Everyone has the inherent right to life, and no one shall be unjustly deprived of that right, according to Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
  • The ICCPR forbids the inhumane, humiliating, and cruel treatment of detainees. No one shall be detained or arrested on an arbitrary basis.

United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners, 2015:

  • Discrimination against inmates on the basis of race, colour, sex, language, religion, political opinion, national or social origin, property, birth, or any other status is prohibited by Section 6 of the Convention.
  • According to Section 7 of the Convention, a register must be kept to record a prisoner's identification, motivations for his acts, and the dates on which he was brought into custody and released.

Custodial death data in India:

  • 2017–2018 had a total of 146 occurrences of deaths while in police custody, followed by 136 in 2018–2019, 112 in 2019–2020, 100 in 2020–2021, and 175 in 2021–2022.
  • Gujarat has reported the most custodial deaths (80) in the past five years, followed by Maharashtra (76), Uttar Pradesh (41), Tamil Nadu (40), and Bihar (40). (38).
  • In 201 cases, the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has recommended financial relief, and in one case, disciplinary action.

Causes for the custodial death:

  • No actual prison reforms exist since the entire prison system is already opaque, which leaves little room for change. India's jails continue to suffer from subpar conditions, overcrowding, severe labor shortages, and inadequate protection from injury.
  • Workplace Stress - The police labor under tremendous strain, and when a swift resolution to complicated cases is required, they turn to violence to elicit confessions and evidence.
  • Social Factor: In keeping with the principle of "an eye for an eye," those in positions of authority opt to employ violence to extract information from those who are accused of committing crimes.
  • Absence of Effective Law: India lacks a strong anti-torture law and has not yet made incarceration violence a crime. Meanwhile, real action against responsible officials is still a pipe dream.
  • Excessive Force: The use of excessive force, including torture, against marginalized groups and individuals who support movements or ideas that the state deems to be inimical to its interests.
  • Long judicial procedures: The poor and the vulnerable are discouraged by the lengthy, expensive formal procedures that courts follow.
  • Not adhering to international standards: Although India ratified the United Nations Convention against Torture in 1997, its provisions have not yet been made mandatory in that nation.

Court judgment on custodial death:

Joginder Kumar v. State of U.P and others, 1994

  • The Court stated in this precedent-setting judgement that the rights guaranteed by Articles 21 and 22(1) of the Constitution must be recognised and upheld. To safeguard the protection of these rights, the Court adopted a few rules.
  • When the arrested person is brought to the police station, the police officer should inform him or her of their rights.
  • The registry must have a record of who received information on the arrest of the accused and who informed them.
  • The provisions of Articles 21 and 22(1) should be firmly recognised and upheld.
  • The Magistrate will judge whether the police authority has complied with and is adhering to all requirements.

Yashwant and others v. the State of Maharashtra, 2018:

  • The High Court of Bombay condemned nine Maharashtra police officers to three years in prison after they were found guilty of causing a death in custody in 1993. The punishment sentence was increased from three years to seven years each by the Supreme Court, who supported the high court's decision.

What options are there for custody provisions?

Article 21 of the Constitutional Provisions

  • "No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty unless in accordance with the method prescribed by law," declares Article 21.
  • According to Article 21 (Right to Life) of the Indian constitution, the right to be protected against torture is a fundamental one.

"Protection from arrest and custody in certain instances" is provided by Article 22.

  • According to Article 22(1) of the Indian Constitution, the right to legal representation is also a basic right.
  • The seventh schedule of the Indian Constitution designates the police and public order as state subjects.
  • The protection of human rights is essentially the duty of the relevant state government.
  • The role of the central government is to occasionally issue advisories and to have passed the Protection of Human Rights Act (PHR) 1933.
  • It mandates the creation of the National Human Rights Commission and State Human Rights Commissions to investigate claims of human rights abuses by public employees.

Legal Provisions:

  • Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC): Section 41 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) was amended in 2009 to include safeguards to ensure that arrests and detentions for questioning have legal justification and follow established procedures, that arrests are disclosed to loved ones, friends, and the public, and that people are protected by legal representation.
  • Indian Penal Code: Sections 330 and 331 of the Indian Penal Code 1860 outline penalties for harm caused when a confession is demanded.
  • Custodial torture of inmates is a crime that can be prosecuted under IPC sections 302, 304, 304A, and 306.
  • Indian Evidence Act, 1872 protection: According to Section 25 of the Act, a confession given to the police cannot be admitted in court.

Way Forward

  • To entirely outlaw judicial and custodial violence, the right changes must be put in place.
  • The UN Convention Against Torture should be ratified by India as it will require a thorough examination of colonial systems, practices, and procedures for the custody and treatment of those who are arrested, detained, or imprisoned.
  • To prevent any form of violence, police officers must receive specialized training.
  • For the purpose of questioning suspects, separate rooms in police stations with CCTV cameras must be put up.
  • The requirements of human rights must be followed regarding prison conditions.
  • Implementation of the Law Commission of India's 273rd Report, which recommends that individuals accused of torturing people in custody, including members of the armed forces and paramilitary groups, be criminally prosecuted in order to provide an effective deterrent

Source: The Indian Express

Speaker of the  Lok Sabha

GS-II : Indian Polity Parliament

Speaker of the Lok Sabha

  • In India, the Office of the Speaker is a dynamic institution that responds to the demands and issues that Parliament really faces as it carries out its duties.
  • The Speaker and Deputy Speaker are both elected under Article 93 of the Constitution.
  • The Speaker is the House's official head both legally and ceremonially.
  • The presiding officer of each House of Parliament is different.
  • For the Lok Sabha, there is a Speaker and a Deputy Speaker, while for the Rajya Sabha, there is a Chairman and a Deputy Chairman.

History:

  • Under the terms of the Government of India Act of 1919, the Speaker and Deputy Speaker institutions first appeared in India in 1921. (Montague-Chelmsford Reforms).
  • The Speaker and Vice Speaker were then referred to as the President and the Deputy President, respectively, and this nomenclature persisted until 1947.
  • The designations of President and Deputy President were changed to Speaker and Deputy Speaker, respectively, by the Government of India Act of 1935.
  • Lok Sabha is home to the Speaker's office.
  • The Lok Sabha, the country's highest legislative body, elects the Speaker, who is in charge of the daily operations of the House.
  • One of the first actions of any freshly constituted House is to elect the Speaker of the Lok Sabha.
  • Requirements for the Speaker's Election: According to the Indian Constitution, the Speaker must be a House member.
  • An understanding of the Constitution and the laws of the nation is regarded as a major benefit for the holder of the Office of the Speaker, even though there are no precise requirements set down for being elected as the Speaker.
  • Typically, a member of the governing party is chosen as Speaker. After informal discussions with the leaders of other parties and groupings in the House, the ruling party nominates its candidate in a procedure that has developed over the years.
  • By following this tradition, all members of the House will respect the Speaker after they have been chosen.
  • Voting: A simple majority of the MPs present and voting in the House elects the Speaker (together with the Deputy Speaker) from among the Lok Sabha members.
  • The Prime Minister or the Minister of Parliamentary Affairs often proposes the candidate's name after a choice has been made.
  • Speaker's Term of Office: The Speaker's term in office runs from the day of his or her election to the day before the next Lok Sabha's first meeting (for 5 years).
  • Once elected, the speaker is up for re-election.
  • The Speaker remains in office until the newly-elected Lok Sabha convenes whenever the Lok Sabha is dissolved.

The importance of the Lok Sabha Speaker's office:

  • The members of Parliament represent the various constituencies, whereas the Speaker symbolizes the full authority of the House.
  • The Speaker's position symbolizes the honour, power, and dignity of the House that he or she is in charge of.
  • The Speaker is regarded as the genuine defender of parliamentary democracy's customs.
  • The Speaker's activities and decisions are closely watched by the House, thus he or she cannot ignore any aspect of parliamentary procedure.

Removal of speaker:

  • If a motion is approved by an absolute majority of all Lok Sabha members, not just an ordinary majority, the Speaker may be ousted.
  • Also, it is required to notify the committee at least 14 days in advance of moving the resolution.
  • Only after the motion for removal obtains the backing of at least 50 House members will it be taken into consideration and addressed.
  • The Speaker is permitted to speak and participate in the procedures of the House even though a motion to remove the Speaker is being discussed by the House. Also, he or she may vote in the first round but not if the votes are evenly divided.

Speaker's Duties and Powers:

  • The Lok Sabha is led by the Speaker.
  • He or she is the main representative of the House, and his or her decision is definitive in all parliamentary matters.
  • Three things grant the Speaker of the Lok Sabha authority:
  • The Indian Constitution
  • The Lok Sabha's Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business
  • Parliamentary Conventions
  • The Speaker's major duty is to uphold decency and order in the House while it conducts business and governs its activities. In this situation, he or she is in charge.
  • He/she is the final interpreter of the provisions of
  • The Constitution of India
  • The Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business of Lok Sabha
  • Parliamentary precedents
  • In the absence of a quorum, he or she may halt the meeting or adjourn the House's operations.

Voting rights:

  • In the beginning, he or she abstains from voting.
  • But, in the event of a tie, he or she may use a casting vote.
  • During a joint session of the two chambers of Parliament, the Speaker serves as the chair. To break the impasse between the Lok sabha and Rajya Sabha over a measure, the President calls a joint session.
  • On the Leader of the House's request, he or she can permit a "secret" sitting of the House.
  • He or she makes the final determination regarding whether the bill qualifies as a money bill.

Independence of the Lok Sabha Speaker:

The following clauses demonstrate the impartiality and independence of the Lok Sabha Speaker's office:

  • Tenure security and stringent requirements for dismissal.
  • The Consolidated Fund of India is used to pay the Speaker's salaries and benefits, which are set by Parliament (not subject to an annual vote of Parliament).
  • In the Lok Sabha, only substantive motions may discuss or criticise the Speaker's performance or behaviour.
  • The ability to cast a vote is an example of the Speaker acting impartially.

Source: PIB

Quasicrystals

GS-I : Physical Geography Geomorphology

Quasicrystals

  • In the Sand Hills in north-central Nebraska, USA, researchers have located a third naturally occurring source of quasicrystals.

What are Quasicrystals?

  • Quasicrystals are intriguing substances with an unusual confluence of features. They serve as evidence of the strength and beauty of asymmetry in the natural world.

In contrast to conventional crystal:

  • As opposed to conventional crystals, which have their atoms arranged in a set, repeated pattern, quasicrystals have their atoms arranged in a pattern that repeats themselves at random intervals.
  • Because of this departure from the regular arrangement of atoms in solids, quasicrystals are a representation of the strength of irregularity.
  • Due to their chemical and physical characteristics, common salt crystals, like those of sodium chloride (NaCl), acquire a cubic form.
  • The sodium and chloride ions can optimize for characteristics like density and thermal stability due to the cubic arrangement.
  • On the other hand, quasicrystals form in a less ideal pattern that deviates from the cubic structure.
  • They still have remnants of some traumatic experience in the structure of their atomic lattice.

Application:

  • They are employed in the production of razor blades, dental tools, acupuncture and surgical needles, as well as non-stick frying pans.

How were quasicrystals discovered?

  • Dan Shechtman, an American-Israeli physicist, discovered quasicrystals in a lab setting in 1982.
  • 2011's Nobel Prize in Chemistry was bestowed to Dan Shechtman, who discovered quasicrystals.
  • In Russia's Khatyrka meteorite, the first natural quasicrystal was found in 2009.
  • The Khatyrka meteorite is thought to have experienced numerous space impacts over millions of years, subjecting it to extremely high pressure and heat.
  • These circumstances served as the inspiration for physicists' experiments employing "shock synthesis" to produce new quasicrystals in the laboratory.
  • Among the ruins of the Manhattan Project's Trinity test, the first atomic weapon to ever be detonated, scientists found a quasicrystal in 2021.
  • These results imply that the formation of natural quasicrystals takes place in hot, intense environments, similar to the Khatyrka meteorite and the Trinity experiment.

Source: The Hindu

Marburg Virus Disease

GS-III : S&T Health

Marburg Virus Disease

After at least nine fatalities, Equatorial Guinea has verified its first-ever Marburg virus illness epidemic.

About Marburg virus:

  • Humans are susceptible to Marburg virus disease (MVD), formerly known as Marburg hemorrhagic fever.
  • The Filoviridae family includes both the Marburg and the Ebola viruses (filovirus). Although the two diseases are brought on by distinct viruses, they are clinically identical.
  • Haemorrhagic fever is the result of the extremely virulent Marburg virus disease, which is carried by bats and has a fatality rate of up to 88%.
  • It belongs to the same family as the Ebola virus family of pathogens.
  • The disease was first identified in 1967 as a result of two significant epidemics that happened concurrently in Marburg, Frankfurt, and Belgrade, Serbia, as well as in Germany and Germany.
  • The outbreak was linked to laboratory experiments imported from Uganda African green monkeys (Cercopithecus aethiops).
  • Human-Infection: Prolonged exposure to mines or caves where Rousettus bat colonies are present is the original cause of Marburg virus sickness in humans.
  • Megabats from the Old World belonging to the genus Rousettus. They are also known as flying foxes and dog-faced fruit bats.

Transmission:

  • Rousettus aegyptiacus, fruit bats belonging to the Pteropodidae family, are thought to be the Marburg virus's natural hosts.
  • The Marburg virus is conveyed between humans by direct contact with the blood, organs, or other body fluids of infected persons as well as with surfaces and materials that have been contaminated with these fluids. The virus is transmitted to humans from fruit bats.
  • Headache, blood in the vomit, muscle cramps, and bleeding from numerous orifices are all symptoms.
  • Jaundice, pancreatic inflammation, extreme weight loss, liver failure, major bleeding, and multiple organ malfunction are among the symptoms that worsen over time.
  • Making a diagnosis is challenging because many of the illness' symptoms resemble those of typhoid fever and malaria.
  • Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA) and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) testing, however, can be utilised to confirm a case.
  • There is currently no known cure or vaccine for Marburg hemorrhagic fever. The use of supportive hospital therapy is advised.
  • Supportive hospital therapy involves maintaining the patient's blood pressure, oxygen levels, and electrolyte balance as well as treating any aggravating infections and restoring lost blood and clotting components.

Source: The Hindu

Lavani Dance

GS-I : Art and Culture Art Forms

Lavani Dance

  • Lavani dance has recently been the subject of controversy in the State of Maharashtra, as younger female dancers have been charged with vilifying the traditional folk art form.

About Lavani:

  • Lavani, which means "beauty" in Sanskrit, is a traditional folk art form in which female dancers perform on a stage in front of an audience while donning make-up, nine-yard-long sarees in vibrant colours, and ghunghroos (ankle bells).
  • It became well-known during the Peshwa era in the 18th century, when performances were given in front of rulers and for the amusement of weary troops during pauses from battle.
  • There are several subgenres of Lavani, with Shringarik (erotic) being the most well-known. Throughout time, the art became more sanitized, with later performers favoring subtly sensual allusions over overt gestures and lyrics.
  • Lavani dance, which draws inspiration from nature and tells the story of Biruba, their deity, was typically performed by Dhangars or Shepherds living in Solapur. In rural Maharashtra, audiences continue to respond enthusiastically to live performances.
  • Lavani performances generally fall into two categories. Both the Nirguni Lavani and the Shringari Lavani deal with philosophy and sensuality, respectively.
  • More people are familiar with Shrinagri Lavani than Nirguni Lavani, and both are performed onstage and in Bollywood films. The love between a man and a woman is the most significant genre that Shringari Lavani deals with.

Read Also: India's Urban Planning

Source: The Indian Express

Other Related News

09 February,2023
India-Kenya Ties

India-Kenya Ties Following a joint reconnaissance of the coastal region close to the Lamu Archipelago by the warships of both nations, India recently handed over 100 nautical charts to Kenya. The survey was carried out in India by the National Hydrography Office of the Indian Navy.

Surveillance Balloon

Surveillance Balloon Tensions between the United States and China were raised after a high-altitude balloon from China invaded American airspace. A Chinese surveillance balloon that had been seen over US airspace for a few days was shot down by the US. About surveillance or sp

Magnetic Pollution

Magnetic Pollution Magnetite pollution has recently been discovered by some geologists in Kolkata's roadside dust. In regions with considerable vehicular traffic and other polluting sources, pollutants occur more frequently. The quantity of magnetite varies with the volume of traffic on

Operation SADBHAVANA

Operation SADBHAVANA The Indian Army launched Operation Sadbhavana (Goodwill) in the State of Jammu & Kashmir to address the aspirations of people who have been impacted by scrooge of terrorism, which is supported and encouraged by Pakistan. Seven Army Goodwill Schools are now bein

08 February,2023
IFFCO Nano Urea 

IFFCO Nano Urea To lay the cornerstone for the IFFCO nano urea liquid fertilizer factory in Jasidih, the Union Home and Cooperation Minister will travel to Deoghar in Jharkhand. About nano urea:   The chemical fertiliser urea, which is white in colour, artificially supplies nitrog

Save Wetlands Campaign

Save Wetlands Campaign The "Save Wetlands Campaign" was introduced by the Union Minister for Environment, Forestry, and Climate Change in Goa.           This campaign is set up as a "whole of society" effort to conserve wetlands, promoting po

India, UAE & France Trilateral Cooperation Initiative

India, UAE & France Trilateral Cooperation Initiative   In a trilateral cooperation initiative in the areas of business, energy, and defence, India joined the UAE and France. India, France, and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) recently decided to join forces to cooperate on combatin

PM KUSUM SCHEME

PM KUSUM SCHEME By March 2026, the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE) will have installed 30,000 MW of solar power capacity in rural India under  (Pradhan Mantri Kisan Urja Suraksha Evam UtthamMahabhiyan)PM KUSUM. About PM KUSUM: The Ministry of New and R

Toppers

Search By Date

Newsletter Subscription
SMS Alerts

Important Links

UPSC GS Mains Crash Course - RAW Prelims Answer Key 2024